Posts

Showing posts from February, 2022

Revisiting the Debate on Islam vis-à-vis Religious Pluralism

For someone baffled by diversity of religions and comparable zeal and commitment shown by believers to their respective traditions and almost universal fact of someone born in some faith choosing to die in that faith, a few points call for attention.      Our situation resembles that of pilgrims travelling in the night to some unknown destination. Pilgrims are divided into different groups, holding different flags distinct identity of which is not clear during night hours. Pilgrims hold fast to their own groups imagining that others have misidentified the road to the destination. It is not quite clear if the destination is one or how to describe it for many pilgrims. Pilgrims are mostly mistrustful of one another’s travel documents. Many, however, imagine that they are following the well-trodden path of pious ancestors first lit by respective founders. During the dark hours it is not clear if the paths of different pilgrims criss cross. There are some pilgrims who stick to their own re

Muslim Attitude towards Other Faith Communities

 There are, in the Muslim world, amongst masses, Sufis, poets, intellectuals though not amongst most of professional theologians, broadly, three attitudes regarding treating the religious other: a) Taking salvation of non-Muslim believing communities for granted, b) not worrying about it c) considering it to be not an object of enquiry here as it is God’s call while maintaining hope in the dominion of Mercy. Our view regarding salvation of religious other may be substantiated by noting how relations with it are here on earth as they figure in the historical record of community. One can’t here review all the major positions and events but only indicate possibilities that may or mayn’t have been fully realized so far at given place and time.     There has been general amnesty in principle to believers and nonbelievers of all kinds. The Islamic holy text can be and has been interpreted as extending freedom of religion to “disbelievers” or those outside the Abrahamic tradition. None could

Books Published

Image
Muslim Modernism and the Problem of Modern Science Muhammad Maroof Shah Indian Publishers Distributor , 2007, xiv, 318 p., ISBN 81-7341-427-0 View the book on Amazon.in Contents: Preface. 1. Modern science and varieties of Muslim modernism. 2. Muslim modernism, reconstructionist thesis and the problem of appropriating modern science in Islam. 3. Frithjof Schuon's traditionalist critique of modern science. 4. Conceptual confusions in modernist thesis of compatibility between the Quran and modern science. 5. Thesis of compatibility between modern science and Islam from Iqbalian perspective. 6. Legitimating the modern project: Iqbal's interpretation of the idea of finality in Islam. 7. Modernist appropriation of evolution and Iqbal. 8. Muslim modernism and demythologization : Sir Syed, Abduhu and Iqbal perspective. 9. Modernist psychologism and the question of reconstruction of religion: an appraisal of Iqbal's approach. 10. Perennialist critique of modern sci

Understanding Hell as Mercy: Reading Ibn Arabi on some Problems of Afterlife

Image
The deeper or comprehensive meaning of Quranic descriptions about hell as mawla – friend (Q. 57:15) – and umm – mother (Q. 101:9), as something for which we ought to be thankful in the chapter Rehman , and use of such words as azab derived from the root word azb meaning sweet thing haven’t been given due attention by mainstream Muslim scholarship. The distinction of Ibn Arabi lies in providing an alternative understanding of hell that finds deep resonance in our hearts and minds besides opening up new vistas on various verses of the Quran. Ibn Arabi declared that his life-long mission is to broadcast the Mercy centric message of Islam – he deciphered the universe’s relationship to the Breath of the All-Merciful  and need to appreciate the dimension of beauty or aesthetic point of view – so that no servant ever despairs. Let us read how he applies his ontology of mercy to non-believers and hell in light of a few statements and works of William Chittick and Muhammad Khalil.      Ibn

Islam and the Challenge and Opportunity of Religious Pluralism

For Islam that requires affirming all revealed traditions/scriptures, known and unknown, as a condition for being a Muslim and has nurtured a civilization that assimilated/engaged with diverse religious/cultural forms and has, relatively, better record of peaceful coexistence with other traditions and great textual and other resources for building impressive non-exclusivist approaches as in Sufis, poets and Muslim sages, certain pluralistic ideas in the air today present an opportunity and not an embarrassment. The following is a selection from certain influential pluralists that echo Islamic tradition’s respect for difference without degenerating into groundless relativism that leaves no room for the Absolute and the emphasis on uniqueness and special access to truth of diverse traditions.  (It is ironic that exclusivist fundamentalism should have grown in Islamic lands in last two centuries and it is noteworthy that we can trace it to certain pathologies in colonial politics and Orie

Appreciating the Sufi Colour of Jamaat e Islami

Syed Moududi, despite his differences with Sufism, especially its philosophical framing and the perception of divergence of its popular form from sharia , succeeded in translating the core moral and spiritual content of Sufism understood as struggle with the lower self and perfection of virtues in the pages of his work that exudes the perfume of discovery of God by a self consumed by obedience to the Divine Will. Reading Syed Moududi one finds that one is led to take God seriously and in that light see everything else. History and our odyssey get a new meaning with fellowship of God. Sufism, according to its acclaimed Masters, is not the science of states but stations and one can take his critique of world wary intoxicating bliss pursuing indulgent Sufism in positive light. Great Masters of Sufism would thank Syed Moududi for feedback on dangers of abnegating reason, eschewing self criticism and cultistic servile following of so called spiritual guides and pleading for non-attachment t

Who can Resist Invitation of Sufism?

Sufism for the Religious and the Secular in the Postmodern World It is mainly because of Tasawwuf that Islam became a world religion and nurtured a vivifying culture and enviable civilization. The world has been conquered for good by the Sufi poets and thinkers. Sufi argument for religion and God involves the attractive power of the Truth called beauty that everyone finds irresistible as Plato would note. In fact Arabs were caught in the net of the beauty of form and meaning of the eloquent Quran and the aesthetically oriented Persians found in Sufi metaphysics their heart’s voice.      None of the great world religions finds it difficult to engage with Tasawwuf . In fact they stand for certain variant of it as esoteric dimension is everywhere. No great philosopher or poet or historian or culture critic, Western or Eastern, could afford not to appreciate it. No secular mind and no religious genius could fail to be attracted to some aspect of it. The Sufis have been ruling hearts and m